dojo wars…dont get any on ya. Pt.2


As I have come to understand it, the Filipino Arts as commercial ventures in America can be traced to a small handful of “masters”. While there have been a number of people teaching the art in the US to individuals or small groups for many years, a couple of notable figures can be credited with its sudden popularity in American martial arts circles. The art that I am associated with gained popularity via the “seminar circuit”. The master hopped around giving weekend long seminars. He passed out rank certificates based on his opinion of the students skill level and how often they came to the seminars and demonstrated how they were progressing. I think that the masters concept of “rank” and how it was to influence his arts politics was ill conceived. Perhaps it was a cultural issue, perhaps he wasn’t concerned with politics and cared less about people squabbling over titles…either way, passing out rank “willy nilly” with no discernible framework or structure was the foundation upon which a lot of rivalry was formed. To add to the confusion, senior students began to form their own variations and associations with their own rank structures, resulting in rank issued by the master as well as rank titles in their own associations. It was against this backdrop that this particular story unfolded.

For myself, time went by…I did my military service, got married, started having children, got into law enforcement, SWAT, promotions, etc. All the while I kind of existed on the fringe of this martial arts group. I trained with Paul, attended seminars and training with DB and some of his close students. Through Paul I heard the stories about the politics and infighting going on in the Filipino Arts in general and the antics between DB and THin particular. He mentioned that some interesting discussions were taking place on an internet discussion forum and suggested that I take a look. I registered with this forum and shortly found out that the board was not only heavily trafficked by students and associates of TH, it was owned and administered by a student/associate of his as well. Discussion on the Filipino Martial arts quickly divided into what became known as “camps”. The “TH Camp” and the “DBCamp”. Being a childhood friend of Paul’s and of the same mind on many issues I of course agreed with most of the points he made in discussions and my own posts were of obviously similar philosophies. Because of this I was pigeonholed as being a member of the “DB Camp”. Even though I was only bumping into DB on a once or twice a year basis at this time and had no political ax to grind.

The bulk of the controversial posts were about TH and his rank. Admittedly, he was issued a fairly high belt level by the master of the art (for whatever that was worth). What was called into question was his formation of his own association and its separate belt structure. Within this association, TH formed a directors board of people from various arts, some that were his own students and juniors in the art. Eventually he had this board promote him to an extremely high rank. This caused squabbling amongst some senior students over who was the senior most student in the masters art.

It all sounds so juvenile, silly and confusing and to a large extent it is, but there were some good points made regarding various artistic and ethical problems with this too. However, the internet being what IT is, all sorts of silliness ensued on this discussion board. Various “sock puppet” accounts jumped into the mix adding fuel to the fires. Some were obviously the same people posting with different names. Some were girlfriends, friends and students from each “camp”. Names were called, threats were made…the age of the internet makes for some very strange circumstances.

What made our local situation even stranger was the fact that many of the people “getting into each others shit” either resided in or frequented the same geographical area. When you take the “6 degrees of separation” factor and add in close proximity it becomes a matter of time before you are dragged into stupid situations and that’s what eventually happened to me.

Stand by while I try to formulate part 3 without getting myself into more stupid situations. 🙂

5 thoughts on “dojo wars…dont get any on ya. Pt.2”

  1. Based on these first two posts (and your earlier posts warning LE Officers to watch what they post) I think I can see where this slow-motion train wreck is going.
    Would that all these folks putting so much time and energy into getting themselves worked up and angry applied that passion to building their skill and competence at the art over which they’re squabbling.
    Probably too much to ask, though…

  2. Now I am very interested in reading part III when it comes out. This is starting to sound like a familiar Soap Opera, and I wager that for most people reading this saga we can change the name of the style, the group, and the people involved and basically arrive ata story we have either been a part of ourselves or know someone personally who has.

    In the first installment I responded and questioned why the martial arts, after proclaiming to embrace and teach concepts like honor, responsibility, honesty, and integrity, are rife with charlatins, liers, and people who are infected with the sickness of greed and desire for other’s adolation. I posited that many instructor’s teachers first off, failed by taking on students of dubious character and quality, and then failed to to teach them concepts like honor, responsibility, honesty, and integrity. If one subscribes to the idea that martial arts are a vehicle to better oneself, then didn’t DB and TH’s teacher’s fail them? If they weren’t taught concepts like honor, responsibility, honesty, and integrity, then they most likely are unable to teach these concepts to their own students. It’s a cycle of failure.

    In this second installment, some of DB and TH’s student’s behave like their instructors and blindly argue in support of their teacher and then between themselves over perceieved seniority and the legitamcay of their group. They are demonstrating that they have not been taught concepts like honor, responsibility, honesty, and integrity, but rather now act in emulation of thier teacher. At least, they are demonstrating in this example what concepts are imprtant to them and their groups.

    Individuals are ultimately responsible for their own behavior and acts. But can DB and TH’s student’s be blamed for acting like their teachers? If one is looking for a martial arts system or group that teaches the things worth believing in, then one might want to invest a goodly amount of time and effort into choosing a system or group before jumping in. The internet can surely help with this to a degree, but I think the majority of excellent teachers are not to be found on the internet. Why? Because these instructors believe in concepts like honor, responsibility, honesty, and integrity and want to divorce themselves and their group’s reputations from the petty squables and political posturing that the internet lends itself to. Good instructor’s are out there on the net, but I think the bad one’s are the most visable because their sites thend to be so slick and their blogs so politicly charged.

    Unfortunately many indiviuals start teaching long before they are ready to. Unfortunatly, many students are unable to criticly question what they are, or what they are not being taught.

    When human nature is taken into consideration, I supose that these things are going to happen, and always will. When these sorts of things start to raise their ugly heads, I suggest we lower ours, keep our mouths shut and just train- lead by example and refuse to get involved in the politics and the tomfoolery. If the situation gets to the point where the group is no longer what it once was, find another group. Easier said than done I know. But if we don’t, then these soap operas are just going to continue to take place.

  3. This is related to the ranks issue I brought up before.

    Haphazard promotions are the #1 killers of organisations.

    1. Perhaps rank itself is the problem. I think that an argument could be made to treat martial arts more like western sport rather than the Asian model we try to emulate.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s